Equatorial Africa Equatorial Asia Global - Land High Latitude South America - Amazon Temperate Latitudes

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	206.
CanESM5	[-]	206.	206.	206.		205.		0.460	21.8	1.77		0.597	0.441	0.751	0.884	0.623
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	196.	196.	190.		225.		5.99	20.7	1.79		0.593	0.434	0.735	0.998	0.639
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	196.	196.	190.		225.		5.98	20.1	1.94		0.610	0.443	0.702	0.997	0.639
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	196.	196.	190.		225.		5.89	20.3	1.79		0.602	0.437	0.730	0.998	0.641
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	196.	196.	190.		225.		5.98	20.8	1.93		0.597	0.431	0.712	0.999	0.634
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	196.	196.	190.		225.		5.81	21.0	1.79		0.604	0.423	0.737	0.998	0.637
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	188.	188.	190.		225.		-1.34	19.5	1.83		0.668	0.424	0.721	0.995	0.646
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	188.	188.	190.		225.		-1.57	19.8	1.90		0.665	0.416	0.716	0.995	0.642
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	189.	189.	190.		225.		-0.616	18.9	1.82		0.660	0.443	0.731	0.998	0.655
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	189.	189.	190.		225.		-0.945	19.2	1.63		0.665	0.432	0.758	0.997	0.657
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	188.	188.	190.		225.		-1.68	19.3	1.76		0.669	0.427	0.727	0.994	0.649
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	176.	176.	190.		225.		-13.4	24.8	1.55		0.473	0.440	0.768	0.918	0.608
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	176.	176.	190.		225.		-13.5	25.4	1.70		0.472	0.434	0.747	0.916	0.601
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	177.	177.	190.		225.		-13.0	25.0	1.59		0.475	0.438	0.778	0.908	0.607
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	176.	176.	190.		225.		-13.5	25.0	1.63		0.468	0.445	0.768	0.914	0.608
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	178.	178.	190.		225.		-12.2	24.8	1.61		0.480	0.431	0.763	0.916	0.604
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	209.	209.	206.		205.		3.06	25.6	2.09		0.625	0.345	0.681	0.951	0.589
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	200.	200.	206.		205.		-5.26	26.6	2.06		0.477	0.462	0.681	0.722	0.561
NorESM2-LM	[-]	200.	200.	206.		205.		-5.75	20.3	1.54		0.622	0.460	0.763	0.959	0.653
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	212.	212.	206.		205.		6.31	19.9	1.27		0.604	0.486	0.826	0.871	0.654

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	201.
CanESM5	[-]	202.	202.	201.				0.957	17.1	1.42		0.645	0.590	0.809	0.996	0.726
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	177.	177.	188.		208.		-11.2	20.5	1.46		0.520	0.565	0.799	0.875	0.665
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	180.	180.	188.		208.		-8.14	19.9	1.54		0.556	0.532	0.786	0.839	0.649
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	179.	179.	188.		208.		-9.33	18.8	1.40		0.546	0.570	0.800	0.886	0.675
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	179.	179.	188.		208.		-8.92	19.4	1.47		0.542	0.551	0.799	0.878	0.664
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	178.	178.	188.		208.		-9.76	20.1	1.29		0.531	0.545	0.824	0.890	0.667
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	169.	169.	188.		208.		-18.8	23.9	1.71		0.416	0.542	0.751	0.945	0.639
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	171.	171.	188.		208.		-17.1	22.7	1.71		0.447	0.537	0.752	0.954	0.645
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	169.	169.	188.		208.		-18.7	23.8	1.65		0.420	0.548	0.765	0.952	0.647
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	169.	169.	188.		208.		-19.2	24.5	1.42		0.409	0.558	0.790	0.966	0.656
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	170.	170.	188.		208.		-18.6	23.1	1.44		0.422	0.577	0.790	0.957	0.664
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	155.	155.	188.		208.		-33.4	37.3	1.71		0.227	0.483	0.760	0.992	0.589
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	156.	156.	188.		208.		-32.0	36.5	1.61		0.241	0.474	0.767	0.995	0.590
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	157.	157.	188.		208.		-30.9	35.2	1.43		0.254	0.484	0.796	0.995	0.603
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	154.	154.	188.		208.		-34.1	38.0	1.47		0.219	0.491	0.798	0.992	0.598
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	156.	156.	188.		208.		-31.8	36.3	1.55		0.248	0.482	0.788	0.988	0.598
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	199.	199.	201.				-2.37	23.9	1.31		0.567	0.567	0.812	0.699	0.643
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	192.	192.	201.				-9.37	20.7	1.69		0.607	0.527	0.735	0.848	0.649
NorESM2-LM	[-]	200.	200.	201.				-0.828	14.6	1.41		0.770	0.588	0.790	0.963	0.740
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	207.	207.	201.				5.29	16.7	1.34		0.678	0.602	0.808	0.998	0.738

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	143.
CanESM5	[-]	146.	146.	143.		140.		3.16	17.3	0.727		0.763	0.728	0.921	0.996	0.827
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	145.	145.	141.		169.		3.70	16.7	0.719		0.778	0.723	0.923	0.996	0.829
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	145.	145.	141.		169.		3.41	16.6	0.712		0.783	0.722	0.922	0.996	0.829
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	145.	145.	141.		169.		3.51	16.6	0.712		0.780	0.723	0.923	0.996	0.829
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	145.	145.	141.		169.		3.60	16.6	0.741		0.780	0.722	0.921	0.996	0.828
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	145.	145.	141.		169.		3.45	16.6	0.718		0.781	0.722	0.923	0.996	0.829
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	143.	143.	141.		169.		2.07	15.8	0.748		0.793	0.728	0.917	0.998	0.833
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	143.	143.	141.		169.		2.07	15.7	0.763		0.796	0.727	0.917	0.998	0.833
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	143.	143.	141.		169.		2.04	15.8	0.720		0.792	0.727	0.920	0.998	0.833
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	143.	143.	141.		169.		2.24	15.7	0.715		0.791	0.730	0.923	0.998	0.834
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	143.	143.	141.		169.		2.05	15.8	0.738		0.793	0.728	0.920	0.998	0.833
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	139.	139.	141.		169.		-2.12	17.0	0.695		0.776	0.714	0.924	0.997	0.825
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	139.	139.	141.		169.		-2.40	16.8	0.707		0.779	0.716	0.923	0.997	0.826
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	139.	139.	141.		169.		-2.25	16.9	0.707		0.779	0.715	0.922	0.997	0.825
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	139.	139.	141.		169.		-2.23	16.9	0.694		0.777	0.716	0.926	0.997	0.826
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	139.	139.	141.		169.		-2.16	17.1	0.693		0.778	0.711	0.924	0.997	0.824
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	148.	148.	143.		149.		4.95	19.3	0.703		0.753	0.693	0.922	0.995	0.811
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	149.	149.	143.		140.		5.38	19.2	0.677		0.729	0.700	0.922	0.990	0.808
NorESM2-LM	[-]	145.	145.	143.		149.		1.59	17.9	0.655		0.759	0.716	0.930	0.991	0.822
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	147.	147.	143.		147.		3.79	14.6	0.686		0.793	0.754	0.925	0.997	0.844

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	76.5
CanESM5	[-]	75.7	75.7	76.6		68.0		-0.881	14.0	0.330		0.898	0.827	0.977	0.989	0.903
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	80.0	80.0	81.4		69.7		-1.38	15.8	0.412		0.902	0.810	0.972	0.986	0.896
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	79.6	79.6	81.4		69.7		-1.77	15.8	0.425		0.904	0.809	0.972	0.989	0.897
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	79.7	79.7	81.4		69.7		-1.70	15.5	0.455		0.902	0.814	0.970	0.987	0.897
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	80.0	80.0	81.4		69.7		-1.40	15.8	0.443		0.901	0.810	0.971	0.987	0.896
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	79.7	79.7	81.4		69.7		-1.71	15.4	0.462		0.904	0.814	0.969	0.990	0.898
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	82.1	82.1	81.4		69.7		0.732	14.4	0.473		0.908	0.824	0.969	0.994	0.904
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	81.5	81.5	81.4		69.7		0.139	14.5	0.465		0.907	0.823	0.969	0.994	0.903
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	81.8	81.8	81.4		69.7		0.412	14.7	0.411		0.907	0.821	0.973	0.993	0.903
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	81.5	81.5	81.4		69.7		0.162	14.2	0.465		0.909	0.827	0.969	0.994	0.905
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	81.8	81.8	81.4		69.7		0.417	14.6	0.460		0.908	0.822	0.969	0.994	0.903
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	79.5	79.5	81.4		69.7		-1.90	15.3	0.311		0.904	0.816	0.979	0.991	0.902
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	79.2	79.2	81.4		69.7		-2.13	15.2	0.408		0.906	0.816	0.973	0.993	0.901
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	79.2	79.2	81.4		69.7		-2.17	15.1	0.330		0.904	0.818	0.978	0.991	0.902
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	79.4	79.4	81.4		69.7		-1.97	14.8	0.405		0.906	0.821	0.973	0.992	0.903
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	79.1	79.1	81.4		69.7		-2.31	15.2	0.355		0.905	0.817	0.976	0.993	0.902
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	81.5	81.5	76.5		81.4		5.00	15.9	0.264		0.896	0.799	0.982	0.993	0.894
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	81.4	81.4	76.6		68.0		4.83	14.1	0.338		0.882	0.827	0.978	0.994	0.902
NorESM2-LM	[-]	68.1	68.1	76.5		81.4		-8.39	17.7	0.428		0.851	0.794	0.971	0.988	0.880
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	75.6	75.6	76.5		77.4		-0.846	12.2	0.368		0.928	0.841	0.976	0.997	0.916

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	175.
CanESM5	[-]	208.	208.	175.				33.3	39.2	2.15		0.178	0.384	0.681	0.998	0.525
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	194.	194.	174.		217.		20.9	28.7	1.89		0.340	0.408	0.719	0.936	0.562
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	195.	195.	174.		217.		21.0	28.2	1.68		0.343	0.412	0.749	0.926	0.568
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	194.	194.	174.		217.		20.9	28.9	1.68		0.345	0.408	0.744	0.943	0.569
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	194.	194.	174.		217.		20.1	28.4	1.78		0.358	0.406	0.739	0.923	0.566
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	194.	194.	174.		217.		20.5	28.6	1.80		0.352	0.402	0.724	0.942	0.564
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	187.	187.	174.		217.		13.5	25.7	1.93		0.452	0.385	0.699	0.892	0.563
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	186.	186.	174.		217.		12.8	25.3	1.89		0.477	0.377	0.716	0.896	0.569
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	187.	187.	174.		217.		13.4	26.2	1.98		0.465	0.367	0.692	0.898	0.558
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	189.	189.	174.		217.		15.5	27.3	1.80		0.430	0.365	0.721	0.896	0.555
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	187.	187.	174.		217.		13.6	25.9	1.80		0.458	0.375	0.729	0.873	0.562
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	184.	184.	174.		217.		10.9	27.8	1.79		0.530	0.295	0.732	0.978	0.566
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	184.	184.	174.		217.		10.1	27.4	1.83		0.540	0.296	0.736	0.984	0.570
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	184.	184.	174.		217.		10.0	26.9	1.96		0.538	0.309	0.710	0.980	0.569
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	184.	184.	174.		217.		10.4	27.4	1.66		0.537	0.295	0.761	0.978	0.573
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	186.	186.	174.		217.		12.1	28.7	1.87		0.517	0.284	0.723	0.980	0.557
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	195.	195.	175.				20.2	32.3	1.28		0.298	0.310	0.811	0.920	0.530
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	188.	188.	175.				12.7	22.0	1.55		0.429	0.481	0.771	0.784	0.589
NorESM2-LM	[-]	188.	188.	175.				13.3	23.3	1.59		0.447	0.415	0.782	0.905	0.593
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	195.	195.	175.				20.3	26.1	2.75		0.341	0.419	0.560	0.947	0.537

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	120.
CanESM5	[-]	118.	118.	120.		127.		-2.04	15.7	0.534		0.874	0.831	0.954	0.997	0.897
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	118.	118.	117.		124.		1.05	15.5	0.493		0.900	0.823	0.965	0.992	0.901
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	117.	117.	117.		124.		0.192	15.5	0.470		0.903	0.820	0.968	0.994	0.901
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	118.	118.	117.		124.		0.661	15.2	0.497		0.902	0.824	0.966	0.992	0.902
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	118.	118.	117.		124.		0.769	15.4	0.509		0.901	0.822	0.965	0.993	0.901
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	118.	118.	117.		124.		0.369	15.2	0.515		0.904	0.824	0.965	0.993	0.902
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	119.	119.	117.		124.		1.88	14.4	0.496		0.900	0.838	0.966	0.997	0.908
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	119.	119.	117.		124.		1.63	14.5	0.531		0.901	0.836	0.963	0.996	0.906
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	119.	119.	117.		124.		1.63	14.7	0.437		0.901	0.833	0.971	0.997	0.907
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	119.	119.	117.		124.		1.66	14.2	0.501		0.903	0.839	0.966	0.996	0.908
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	119.	119.	117.		124.		1.71	14.6	0.536		0.901	0.835	0.963	0.996	0.906
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	117.	117.	117.		124.		-0.570	14.1	0.416		0.903	0.843	0.971	0.996	0.911
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	116.	116.	117.		124.		-1.21	14.0	0.469		0.908	0.841	0.968	0.997	0.911
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	116.	116.	117.		124.		-1.12	14.1	0.421		0.906	0.840	0.971	0.996	0.911
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	117.	117.	117.		124.		-0.431	13.7	0.475		0.907	0.845	0.968	0.995	0.912
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	116.	116.	117.		124.		-1.07	14.0	0.423		0.907	0.841	0.971	0.996	0.911
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	123.	123.	120.		127.		3.02	17.3	0.503		0.884	0.803	0.963	0.995	0.890
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	122.	122.	120.		127.		2.50	15.6	0.470		0.874	0.832	0.958	0.995	0.898
NorESM2-LM	[-]	119.	119.	120.		127.		-1.28	16.5	0.498		0.852	0.832	0.962	0.955	0.887
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	119.	119.	120.		128.		-0.716	13.8	0.483		0.912	0.832	0.964	0.998	0.908

Equatorial Africa Equatorial Asia Global - Land High Latitude South America - Amazon Temperate Latitudes Temporally integrated period mean Temporally integrated period mean max month Temporally integrated mean phase shift Temporally integrated mean phase shift score Temporally integrated period mean bias Temporally integrated period mean bias score Temporally integrated period mean rmse Temporally integrated period mean rmse score Spatially integrated regional mean cycle Spatially integrated regional mean detrended cycle Spatially integrated regional mean

  Title:

CERES EBAF TOA and Surface Fluxes. Monthly Averages and 07/2005 to 06/2015 Climatology.

  Version:

Edition 4.2

Release Date February 10, 2023

  Institution:

NASA Langley Research Center

  References:

Loeb, N. G., D. R. Doelling, H. Wang, W. Su, C. Nguyen, J. G. Corbett, L. Liang, C. Mitrescu, F. G. Rose, and S. Kato (2018), Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) Top-of-Atmosphere (TOA) Edition-4.0 Data Product, J. Climate, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0208.1

Kato, S., F. G. Rose, D. A. Rutan, T. E. Thorsen, N. G. Loeb, D. R. Doelling, X. Huang, W. L. Smith, W. Su, and S.-H. Ham (2018), Surface irradiances of Edition 4.0 Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) data product, J. Climate, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0523.1

  Conventions:

CF-1.4

  Comment:

Climatology from 07/2005 to 06/2015

  Doi:

10.5067/TERRA-AQUA-NOAA20/CERES/EBAF_L3B004.2