Equatorial Africa Equatorial Asia Global - Land High Latitude South America - Amazon Temperate Latitudes

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	452.
CanESM5	[-]	460.	460.	452.		454.		8.25	12.0	0.849		0.402	0.551	0.907	0.984	0.679
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	456.	456.	448.		458.		8.64	13.1	0.952		0.415	0.536	0.875	0.999	0.672
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	456.	456.	448.		458.		8.70	13.1	1.06		0.410	0.542	0.855	0.999	0.670
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	456.	456.	448.		458.		8.73	13.4	1.08		0.409	0.546	0.855	0.999	0.671
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	456.	456.	448.		458.		8.60	13.3	0.999		0.413	0.530	0.867	0.999	0.668
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	456.	456.	448.		458.		8.70	13.4	1.05		0.413	0.535	0.859	0.998	0.668
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	458.	458.	448.		458.		9.88	14.7	0.983		0.349	0.557	0.871	0.998	0.666
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	457.	457.	448.		458.		9.32	14.6	1.17		0.359	0.547	0.839	0.998	0.658
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	458.	458.	448.		458.		10.1	14.8	1.01		0.345	0.569	0.869	0.998	0.670
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	457.	457.	448.		458.		9.68	14.3	1.16		0.357	0.556	0.839	0.997	0.661
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	457.	457.	448.		458.		9.41	14.5	1.10		0.355	0.556	0.847	0.999	0.663
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	450.	450.	448.		458.		2.30	10.5	1.04		0.518	0.535	0.862	0.988	0.687
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	449.	449.	448.		458.		1.84	10.4	1.13		0.528	0.527	0.842	0.989	0.682
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	450.	450.	448.		458.		2.30	10.6	1.10		0.522	0.527	0.854	0.989	0.684
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	449.	449.	448.		458.		1.65	10.3	0.976		0.537	0.533	0.869	0.984	0.691
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	450.	450.	448.		458.		2.76	10.6	1.00		0.512	0.528	0.866	0.987	0.684
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	457.	457.	452.		455.		5.57	10.5	0.855		0.472	0.558	0.905	0.952	0.689
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	454.	454.	452.		454.		2.49	10.2	0.968		0.489	0.586	0.883	0.997	0.708
NorESM2-LM	[-]	465.	465.	452.		455.		13.5	15.5	1.04		0.301	0.554	0.880	0.962	0.650
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	464.	464.	452.		455.		12.4	14.3	0.841		0.375	0.595	0.909	0.999	0.695

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	465.
CanESM5	[-]	471.	471.	465.				6.80	7.94	1.67		0.346	0.640	0.737	0.694	0.611
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	454.	454.	454.		470.		0.939	8.35	1.45		0.292	0.580	0.788	0.869	0.622
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	455.	455.	454.		470.		1.45	8.50	1.41		0.287	0.569	0.783	0.879	0.617
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	455.	455.	454.		470.		1.48	8.49	1.43		0.287	0.577	0.784	0.880	0.621
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	455.	455.	454.		470.		1.28	8.45	1.54		0.289	0.573	0.775	0.881	0.619
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	454.	454.	454.		470.		0.891	8.43	1.51		0.291	0.579	0.773	0.879	0.620
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	457.	457.	454.		470.		3.06	8.69	1.57		0.286	0.567	0.768	0.910	0.620
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	456.	456.	454.		470.		2.75	8.65	1.44		0.286	0.579	0.782	0.920	0.629
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	457.	457.	454.		470.		3.02	8.66	1.60		0.286	0.578	0.769	0.912	0.625
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	456.	456.	454.		470.		2.61	8.55	1.63		0.288	0.574	0.761	0.915	0.622
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	457.	457.	454.		470.		3.12	8.70	1.55		0.286	0.589	0.771	0.915	0.630
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	453.	453.	454.		470.		-0.977	8.16	1.71		0.318	0.556	0.744	0.895	0.613
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	452.	452.	454.		470.		-1.43	8.19	1.76		0.326	0.541	0.730	0.898	0.607
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	452.	452.	454.		470.		-1.25	8.18	1.80		0.322	0.547	0.734	0.898	0.609
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	452.	452.	454.		470.		-1.60	8.20	1.70		0.328	0.538	0.735	0.893	0.606
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	452.	452.	454.		470.		-1.07	8.16	1.79		0.321	0.550	0.737	0.903	0.612
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	470.	470.	465.				5.07	6.85	2.29		0.370	0.576	0.620	0.877	0.604
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	467.	467.	465.				2.19	8.19	2.39		0.383	0.420	0.622	0.751	0.519
NorESM2-LM	[-]	476.	476.	465.				11.6	12.1	2.37		0.151	0.595	0.628	0.775	0.549
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	471.	471.	465.				6.10	7.34	1.22		0.442	0.604	0.818	0.698	0.633

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	377.
CanESM5	[-]	379.	379.	376.		395.		2.15	16.2	0.525		0.672	0.734	0.942	0.999	0.816
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	378.	378.	374.		407.		3.75	13.6	0.489		0.715	0.748	0.950	1.00	0.832
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	378.	378.	374.		407.		3.37	13.5	0.503		0.720	0.744	0.947	1.00	0.831
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	378.	378.	374.		407.		3.64	13.7	0.513		0.716	0.745	0.947	1.00	0.830
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	378.	378.	374.		407.		3.70	13.7	0.510		0.716	0.745	0.950	1.00	0.831
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	378.	378.	374.		407.		3.41	13.6	0.484		0.718	0.745	0.951	1.00	0.832
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	382.	382.	374.		407.		7.42	15.2	0.525		0.677	0.747	0.947	1.00	0.824
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	381.	381.	374.		407.		6.75	14.7	0.505		0.688	0.749	0.949	1.00	0.827
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	381.	381.	374.		407.		6.87	15.2	0.501		0.681	0.745	0.948	1.00	0.824
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	381.	381.	374.		407.		6.85	14.8	0.503		0.685	0.746	0.948	1.00	0.825
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	381.	381.	374.		407.		6.91	15.0	0.511		0.681	0.747	0.949	1.00	0.825
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	376.	376.	374.		407.		1.21	13.6	0.508		0.726	0.739	0.945	0.999	0.830
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	375.	375.	374.		407.		0.214	13.4	0.510		0.734	0.738	0.945	0.999	0.831
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	375.	375.	374.		407.		0.235	13.3	0.494		0.735	0.740	0.946	1.00	0.832
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	375.	375.	374.		407.		0.802	13.6	0.496		0.729	0.737	0.947	0.999	0.830
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	375.	375.	374.		407.		0.619	13.5	0.508		0.732	0.734	0.946	1.00	0.829
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	378.	378.	376.		417.		1.94	13.8	0.539		0.706	0.753	0.943	0.999	0.831
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	386.	386.	376.		395.		9.10	17.6	0.495		0.643	0.736	0.945	0.985	0.809
NorESM2-LM	[-]	386.	386.	376.		417.		9.37	17.1	0.650		0.640	0.727	0.935	0.999	0.805
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	380.	380.	376.		409.		3.66	13.0	0.493		0.713	0.749	0.946	0.999	0.831

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	305.
CanESM5	[-]	305.	305.	305.		324.		-0.350	12.9	0.163		0.771	0.819	0.988	0.997	0.879
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	307.	307.	298.		315.		8.23	14.3	0.102		0.840	0.828	0.993	1.00	0.898
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	306.	306.	298.		315.		7.24	13.8	0.0821		0.853	0.826	0.994	1.00	0.900
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	306.	306.	298.		315.		8.05	14.6	0.114		0.841	0.822	0.992	1.00	0.895
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	307.	307.	298.		315.		8.45	14.6	0.110		0.836	0.829	0.992	0.999	0.897
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	306.	306.	298.		315.		8.14	14.1	0.0689		0.842	0.828	0.995	1.00	0.899
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	313.	313.	298.		315.		14.3	18.7	0.0812		0.762	0.821	0.994	1.00	0.880
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	311.	311.	298.		315.		12.9	17.7	0.0819		0.782	0.821	0.994	1.00	0.884
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	312.	312.	298.		315.		13.2	18.1	0.0943		0.777	0.816	0.994	1.00	0.881
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	311.	311.	298.		315.		12.9	17.6	0.0764		0.780	0.821	0.995	1.00	0.883
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	312.	312.	298.		315.		13.2	17.9	0.0796		0.776	0.821	0.994	1.00	0.882
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	306.	306.	298.		315.		7.65	13.7	0.0697		0.850	0.830	0.995	1.00	0.901
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	305.	305.	298.		315.		6.18	13.1	0.0795		0.866	0.828	0.994	1.00	0.903
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	304.	304.	298.		315.		5.55	12.7	0.0701		0.873	0.831	0.995	1.00	0.906
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	306.	306.	298.		315.		7.24	13.5	0.0991		0.854	0.832	0.993	1.00	0.902
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	304.	304.	298.		315.		6.04	13.1	0.0720		0.870	0.826	0.995	1.00	0.903
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	312.	312.	305.		347.		7.08	13.8	0.194		0.794	0.761	0.981	0.999	0.859
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	309.	309.	305.		324.		4.33	14.4	0.183		0.752	0.818	0.986	0.997	0.874
NorESM2-LM	[-]	310.	310.	305.		347.		5.36	14.3	0.310		0.789	0.779	0.978	1.00	0.865
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	300.	300.	305.		339.		-5.25	11.9	0.154		0.802	0.831	0.989	0.984	0.887

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	444.
CanESM5	[-]	472.	472.	444.				28.0	32.6	1.44		0.110	0.268	0.794	0.736	0.435
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	451.	451.	443.		462.		7.70	10.4	1.46		0.334	0.551	0.792	0.969	0.639
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	451.	451.	443.		462.		7.84	10.6	1.54		0.332	0.538	0.780	0.968	0.631
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	451.	451.	443.		462.		7.81	10.8	1.48		0.333	0.529	0.793	0.970	0.631
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	450.	450.	443.		462.		7.32	10.3	1.23		0.347	0.553	0.844	0.972	0.654
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	450.	450.	443.		462.		7.33	10.3	1.31		0.350	0.537	0.824	0.970	0.643
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	453.	453.	443.		462.		10.4	12.5	1.44		0.251	0.554	0.791	0.961	0.622
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	453.	453.	443.		462.		9.83	12.1	1.27		0.266	0.571	0.829	0.963	0.640
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	453.	453.	443.		462.		10.2	12.4	1.55		0.256	0.547	0.775	0.963	0.618
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	453.	453.	443.		462.		10.0	12.2	1.37		0.262	0.529	0.804	0.960	0.617
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	453.	453.	443.		462.		10.3	12.6	1.17		0.254	0.558	0.848	0.964	0.636
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	452.	452.	443.		462.		8.64	12.2	1.63		0.306	0.492	0.760	0.948	0.600
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	451.	451.	443.		462.		7.79	11.5	1.58		0.323	0.487	0.772	0.952	0.604
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	451.	451.	443.		462.		8.08	11.6	1.64		0.319	0.509	0.760	0.951	0.610
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	451.	451.	443.		462.		7.84	11.5	1.54		0.324	0.504	0.779	0.948	0.612
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	452.	452.	443.		462.		8.94	12.4	1.59		0.299	0.488	0.766	0.945	0.597
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	456.	456.	444.				11.8	13.6	1.18		0.240	0.615	0.837	0.997	0.661
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	450.	450.	444.				6.11	12.6	1.62		0.281	0.505	0.780	0.997	0.613
NorESM2-LM	[-]	457.	457.	444.				12.9	15.1	1.13		0.219	0.506	0.863	0.994	0.618
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	460.	460.	444.				16.1	18.8	2.18		0.203	0.377	0.674	0.994	0.525

	Download Data	Period Mean (original grids) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (intersection) [W m-2]	Model Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]	Benchmark Period Mean (complement) [W m-2]		Bias [W m-2]	RMSE [W m-2]	Phase Shift [months]		Bias Score [1]	RMSE Score [1]	Seasonal Cycle Score [1]	Spatial Distribution Score [1]	Overall Score [1]
Benchmark	[-]	351.
CanESM5	[-]	351.	351.	351.		376.		0.576	13.9	0.174		0.758	0.810	0.988	0.998	0.873
E3SMv3 default 0051	[-]	342.	342.	337.		372.		5.48	13.7	0.165		0.843	0.841	0.989	0.997	0.902
E3SMv3 default 0111	[-]	341.	341.	337.		372.		4.34	13.3	0.157		0.854	0.839	0.989	0.996	0.904
E3SMv3 default 0161	[-]	342.	342.	337.		372.		5.09	13.7	0.171		0.847	0.836	0.989	0.996	0.901
E3SMv3 default 0281	[-]	342.	342.	337.		372.		5.35	13.7	0.228		0.842	0.843	0.985	0.997	0.902
E3SMv3 default 0311	[-]	341.	341.	337.		372.		4.93	13.3	0.152		0.850	0.841	0.990	0.995	0.903
E3SMv3 highECS 0051	[-]	347.	347.	337.		372.		10.5	16.7	0.209		0.791	0.838	0.986	0.995	0.889
E3SMv3 highECS 0111	[-]	346.	346.	337.		372.		9.51	16.0	0.189		0.802	0.840	0.987	0.996	0.893
E3SMv3 highECS 0161	[-]	346.	346.	337.		372.		9.28	16.2	0.167		0.802	0.835	0.989	0.994	0.891
E3SMv3 highECS 0281	[-]	346.	346.	337.		372.		9.45	16.1	0.167		0.802	0.836	0.989	0.995	0.892
E3SMv3 highECS 0311	[-]	346.	346.	337.		372.		9.75	16.2	0.175		0.798	0.840	0.988	0.996	0.892
E3SMv3 lowECS 0051	[-]	341.	341.	337.		372.		4.43	13.2	0.123		0.851	0.845	0.992	0.996	0.906
E3SMv3 lowECS 0111	[-]	339.	339.	337.		372.		2.76	12.5	0.142		0.866	0.844	0.990	0.994	0.908
E3SMv3 lowECS 0161	[-]	340.	340.	337.		372.		3.05	12.2	0.122		0.866	0.848	0.992	0.996	0.910
E3SMv3 lowECS 0281	[-]	341.	341.	337.		372.		4.56	12.8	0.140		0.853	0.849	0.991	0.997	0.908
E3SMv3 lowECS 0311	[-]	340.	340.	337.		372.		3.29	12.4	0.150		0.866	0.844	0.990	0.996	0.908
IPSL-CM6A-LR	[-]	355.	355.	351.		376.		3.79	13.5	0.213		0.765	0.771	0.986	0.995	0.858
MIROC-ES2L	[-]	356.	356.	351.		376.		4.65	14.8	0.211		0.725	0.811	0.986	0.978	0.862
NorESM2-LM	[-]	359.	359.	351.		376.		8.45	14.5	0.271		0.760	0.796	0.982	1.00	0.867
UKESM1-0-LL	[-]	350.	350.	351.		377.		-0.520	9.56	0.134		0.837	0.843	0.991	0.999	0.903

Equatorial Africa Equatorial Asia Global - Land High Latitude South America - Amazon Temperate Latitudes Temporally integrated period mean Temporally integrated period mean max month Temporally integrated mean phase shift Temporally integrated mean phase shift score Temporally integrated period mean bias Temporally integrated period mean bias score Temporally integrated period mean rmse Temporally integrated period mean rmse score Spatially integrated regional mean cycle Spatially integrated regional mean detrended cycle Spatially integrated regional mean

  Title:

CERES EBAF TOA and Surface Fluxes. Monthly Averages and 07/2005 to 06/2015 Climatology.

  Version:

Edition 4.2

Release Date February 10, 2023

  Institution:

NASA Langley Research Center

  References:

Loeb, N. G., D. R. Doelling, H. Wang, W. Su, C. Nguyen, J. G. Corbett, L. Liang, C. Mitrescu, F. G. Rose, and S. Kato (2018), Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) Top-of-Atmosphere (TOA) Edition-4.0 Data Product, J. Climate, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0208.1

Kato, S., F. G. Rose, D. A. Rutan, T. E. Thorsen, N. G. Loeb, D. R. Doelling, X. Huang, W. L. Smith, W. Su, and S.-H. Ham (2018), Surface irradiances of Edition 4.0 Clouds and the Earth's Radiant Energy System (CERES) Energy Balanced and Filled (EBAF) data product, J. Climate, doi:10.1175/JCLI-D-17-0523.1

  Conventions:

CF-1.4

  Comment:

Climatology from 07/2005 to 06/2015

  Doi:

10.5067/TERRA-AQUA-NOAA20/CERES/EBAF_L3B004.2